8 March 2018

A Discovering Diamonds review of The Only Blue Door by Joan Fallon

AMAZON UK £4.50 $13.98
AMAZON US $6.29 $16.99 

Family Drama

I approached this book not knowing quite what it was. The title did not reveal much, and for those who associate blue doors and window shutters with Greece I might as well state immediately that this book is not about Greece. At all. Instead, it is about an aspect of history I had never heard of before, namely that of British children sent off on their own as immigrants to Australia and other such “remote” locations.

It all starts with the German bombings of London during World War Two. Due to the sheer confusion and panic in the aftermath of these bombing raids, the Smith siblings are labelled as orphans and sent off abroad, with the eldest, Maggie, feeling very responsible for her brother Billy and little sister Grace.

They are not exactly welcomed with open arms in Australia. Billy is forcibly separated from his sisters,  ending up in one orphanage, the girls in another. The orphanages are run by Catholic orders, and the fact that the Smith children aren’t Catholics is neither here nor there. The author is clearly not impressed by what she’s found during her research of these institutions and does not  portray this as a loving and caring environment, rather the reverse. The monks and nuns responsible for the Smith children and all the other little immigrants show an amazing lack of empathy, making me draw parallels with similar stories from Ireland. So instead of being loved and cuddled, the children are given but rudimentary schooling, after which it is work, work and even more work. 

The central character is Maggie. She takes her role as the eldest very seriously, and while Maggie remains convinced their mother isn’t dead, she goes along with the official story that their mother died in the bombings, thinking it will make it easier for Billy and Grace to adapt. Being the eldest, Maggie is the first to leave the orphanage for a new life outside, but she is torn by worry for little Grace, so unsuited to the harsh life with the nuns, and even more for Billy, whom she hasn’t heard of in years. 

Ms Fallon is a competent writer. Her characters are well-developed, her prose is fluid and her descriptions bring the various settings to life. Nor does she shy away from the fact that this is a story with no Happily Ever After—how can there be? Personally, however, I found the ending somewhat inconclusive, but all in all The Only Blue Door is a gripping read, shedding light on human tragedies I had never heard of before.

© Anna Belfrage

<previous   next >

click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest

How we Discover our Diamonds - a look at how the system works.


  1. Put this book on my wish list, even though my TBR pile has collapsed under its own weight.

    1. Oh I know just what you mean! It gets worrying when you need a step ladder to reach the top of the pile doesn't it... yet we must still buy that next book....


Thank you for leaving a comment - it should appear immediately, but Blogger sometimes chucks its teddies out of the cot and has a tantrum (especially if you are a Wordpress person) If you are having problems, contact me on author AT helenhollick DOT net and I will post it for you.
However, SPAMMERS will be stamped on, squashed, composted and very possibly cursed - if you spam this blog, next time something nasty happens to you just remember that you were warned...